CCNP Route Notes Planning for Complex Networks

CCNP Route Notes Planning for Complex Networks

Network Design Models

Today’s networks typically include voice, video, network management, mission-critical, and routing traffic in addition to bulk user traffic. Each type of traffic has different performance (bandwidth, delay, and jitter) and security requirements. Network design models provide a framework for integrating the many different types of traffic into the network.

Over the years, several models have been used to help describe how a complex network functions. These models are useful for designing a network and for understanding traffic flow within a more complex network. This section covers three models: the traditional Hierarchical Model, the Enterprise Composite Model, and the Cisco Enterprise Model.

The Hierarchical Design Model

Network designers used the three-level Hierarchical Design Model for years. This older model provided a high-level idea of how a reliable network might be conceived, but it was largely conceptual because it didn’t provide specific guidance. Figure 1-1 shows the Hierarchical Design Model.

FIGURE 1-1 Hierarchical Design Model

This is a simple drawing of how the three-layer model might be built out for a campus network. A distribution Layer-3 switch is used for each building on campus, tying together the access switches on the floors. The core switches link the various buildings together.

This same three-layer hierarchy can be used in the WAN with a central headquarters, division headquarters, and units. The layers break a network in the following way:

  • Access layer: Provides network access to workgroup end stations.
  • Distribution layer: Intermediate devices provide connectivity based on policies.
  • Core layer: Provides a high-speed switched path between distribution elements.

Redundant distribution and core devices, with connections, make the model more fault-tolerant. This early model was a good starting point, but it failed to address key issues, such as

  • Where do wireless devices fit in?
  • How should Internet access and security be provisioned?
  • How do you account for remote access, such as dial-up or VPN?
  • Where should workgroup and enterprise services be located?
The Enterprise Composite Model

A newer Cisco model—the Enterprise Composite Model—is significantly more complex and attempts to address the shortcomings of the Hierarchical Design Model by expanding the older version and making specific recommendations about how and where certain network functions should be implemented. This model is a component of the Cisco Security Architecture for Enterprise (SAFE) Reference Architecture.

The Enterprise Model is broken into three large sections:

  • Enterprise Campus: Switches that make up a LAN
  • Enterprise Edge: The portion of the enterprise network connected to the larger world
  • Service Provider Edge: The different public networks that are attached

The Enterprise Campus, as shown in Figure 1-2, looks like the old Hierarchical Design Model with added details. It features six sections:

  • Campus Backbone: The core of the LAN
  • Building Distribution: Connects subnets/VLANs and applies policy
  • Building Access: Connects users to network
  • Management: An out-of-band network to access and manage the devices
  • Edge Distribution: A distribution layer out to the WAN
  • Server Farm: For Enterprise services

FIGURE 1-2  The Enterprise Campus

The Enterprise Edge, as shown in Figure 1-3, details the connections from the campus to the WAN and includes

  • E-commerce
  • Internet connectivity
  • Remote access
  • WAN

FIGURE 1-3 The Enterprise Edge

The Service Provider Edge is just a list of the public networks that facilitate wide-area connectivity and include

  • Internet service provider (ISP)
  • Public switched telephone network (PSTN)
  • Frame Relay, ATM, and PPP

Figure 1-4 puts together the various pieces: Campus, Enterprise Edge, and Service Provider Edge. Security implemented on this model is described in the Cisco SAFE blueprint.

FIGURE 1-4  The Enterprise Composite Model

The Cisco Enterprise Architecture

The Cisco Enterprise Architecture attempts to describe how all the network components integrate and work together. It includes Campus, Data Center, Branch, WAN, and Teleworker components.

The Campus Architecture component is basically the same as in the Composite model. It includes routing and switching integrated with technologies such as IP telephony and is designed for high availability with redundant links and devices.
It integrates security features and provides QoS to ensure application performance. It is flexible enough to add advanced technologies such as VPNs, tunnels, and authentication management.

The Data Center component provides a centralized, scalable architecture that enables virtualization, server and application access, load balancing, and user services. Redundant data centers might be used to provide backup and business continuity.

The Branch Architecture extends enterprise services to remote offices. Network monitoring and management is centralized. Branch networks include access to enterprise-level services such as converged voice and video, security, and application WAN optimization. Resiliency is obtained through backup local call processing, VPNs, redundant WAN links, and application content caching.

The WAN component provides data, voice, and video content to enterprise users any time and any place. QoS, SLAs, and encryption ensure a high-quality secure delivery of resources. It uses IPsec or MPLS VPNs over Layer 2 or Layer 3 WANs, with either a hub-and-spoke or mesh topology.

Teleworker Architecture describes how voice and data are delivered securely to remote small or home office users. It leverages a standard broadband connection, combined with VPN and identity-based access. An IP phone can also be used.


Modern converged networks include different traffic types, each with unique requirements for security, QoS, transmission capacity, and delay. These include

  • Voice signaling and bearer
  • Core application traffic, such as Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) or Customer Relationship Management (CRM)
  • Database transactions
  • Multicast multimedia
  • Network management
  • Other traffic, such as web pages, email, and file transfer

Cisco routers can implement filtering, compression, prioritization, and policing. Except for filtering, these capabilities are referred to collectively as QoS.

Although QoS is a powerful tool, it is not the only way to address bandwidth shortage. Cisco espouses an idea called the
Intelligent Information Network (IIN).

IIN describes an evolutionary vision of a network that integrates network and application functionality cooperatively and enables the network to be smart about how it handles traffic to minimize the footprint of applications. IIN is built on top of the Enterprise Composite Model and describes structures overlaid on to the Composite design as needed in three phases.

Phase 1, “Integrated Transport,” describes a converged network, which is built along the lines of the Composite model and based on open standards. This is the phase that the industry has been transitioning to recently. The Cisco Integrated Services Routers (ISR) are an example of this trend.

Phase 2, “Integrated Services,” attempts to virtualize resources, such as servers, storage, and network access. It is a move
to an “on-demand” model.

By “virtualize,” Cisco means that the services are not associated with a particular device or location. Instead, many services can reside in one device to ease management, or many devices can provide one service. An ISR brings together routing, switching, voice, security, and wireless. It is an example of many services existing on one device. A load balancer, which makes many servers look like one, is an example of one service residing on many devices.

VRFs are an example of taking one resource and making it look like many. Some versions of IOS are capable of having a router present itself as many virtual router (VRF) instances, allowing your company to deliver different logical topologies on the same physical infrastructure. Server virtualization is another example. The classic example of taking one resource and making it appear to be many resources is the use of a virtual LAN (VLAN) and a virtual storage area network (VSAN).

Virtualization provides flexibility in configuration and management.

Phase 3, “Integrated Applications,” uses application-oriented networking (AON) to make the network application-aware
and to enables the network to actively participate in service delivery.

An example of this Phase 3 IIN systems approach to service delivery is Network Admission Control (NAC). Before NAC, authentication, VLAN assignment, and antivirus updates were separately managed. With NAC in place, the network can check the policy stance of a client and admit, deny, or remediate based on policies.

IIN enables the network to deconstruct packets, parse fields, and take actions based on the values it finds. An ISR equipped with an AON blade might be set up to route traffic from a business partner. The AON blade handles many functions, including examining traffic, recognizing an application, and rebuilding XML files in memory. Corrupted XML fields might represent an attack (called schema poisoning), and the AON blade can react by blocking that source from further communication. In this example, routing, an awareness of the application data flow, and security are all combined to enable the network to contribute to the success of the application.

Services-Oriented Network Architecture (SONA) applies the IIN ideal to Enterprise networks. SONA breaks down the IIN functions into three layers:

  • Network Infrastructure: Hierarchical converged network and attached end systems
  • Interactive Services: Resources allocated to applications
  • Applications: Includes business policy and logic

Understanding Routing Protocols

Routing protocols pass information about the structure of the network between routers. Cisco routers support multiple routing protocols, but the ROUTE exam covers only EIGRP, OSPF, and BGP. This section compares routing protocols and calls out some key differences between them.

Administrative Distance

Cisco routers are capable of supporting several IP routing protocols concurrently. When identical prefixes are learned from two or more separate sources, Administrative Distance (AD) is used to discriminate between the paths. AD is a poor choice of words; risk-factor is a more descriptive name. All other things being equal, routers choose paths advertised by the protocol with the lowest AD. AD can be manually adjusted. Table 1-1 lists the default values for various routing protocols.

Table 1-1  Routing Protocols and Their Default Administrative Distance

Information Source AD
Connected 0
Static 1
External BGP (Border Gateway Protocol) 20
Internal EIGRP (Enhanced IGRP) 90
IGRP (Internet Gateway Routing Protocol) 100
OSPF (Open Shortest Path First) 110
IS-IS (Intermediate System to Intermediate System) 115
RIP (Routing Information Protocol) 120
ODR (On Demand Routing) 160
External EIGRP 170
Internal BGP 200
Unknow 255
Routing Protocol Characteristics

Two things should always be considered in choosing a routing protocol: fast convergence speed and support for VLSM. EIGRP, OSPF, and BGP all meet these criteria. There are important distinctions between them, as described here:

  • EIGRP is proprietary, so it can be used only in an all-Cisco network; however, it is simple for network staff to configure and support.
  • OSPF is an open standard, but it is a bit more difficult for network staff to implement and support.
  • BGP is also an open standard but is typically used to exchange routes with routers external to your network. It can be very complex to implement, and fewer network engineers understand it well.

Table 1-2 Comparison of Routing Protocols

Method Advanced distance vector Link state Path vector
Summarization Auto and manual Manual Auto and Manual
VLSM Yes Yes Yes
Convergence Speed Very fast Fast Slow
Timers: Update (hello/dead) Triggered (LAN 5/15, WAN 60/180) Triggered, but LSA refreshes every 30 minutes (NBMA 30/120, LAN 10/40) Triggered (60/180)
Network Size Large Large Very large

Building the Routing Table

The router builds a routing table by ruling out invalid routes and considering the remaining advertisements. The procedure is

  1.  For each route received, verify the next hop. If invalid, discard the route.
  2. If multiple identical, valid routes are received by a routing protocol, choose the lowest metric.
  3. Routes are identical if they advertise the same prefix and mask, so and are separate paths and are each placed into the routing table.
  4. If more than one specific valid route is advertised by different routing protocols, choose the path with the lowest AD.

Choosing a Route

Routers look at the routing table to decide how to forward a packet. They look for a match to the destination IP address. Rarely will a route match the destination IP address exactly, so the router looks for the longest match. For instance, suppose a packet is bound for the IP address The routing table has a route for, one for, and a default route of The default route matches 0 bits of the destination address, the route matches 16 bits of the destination address, and the route matches 24 bits of the destination address. The route is the longest match, so it will be used to forward the packet.

Planning a Routing Implementation

It is critical to take a structured approach to planning a routing implementation and to document thoroughly once you are done. Taking an ad-hoc approach could lead to network instability, suboptimal routing, or scalability problems. Four commonly used models include

  • Cisco Lifestyle Services: Uses the PPDIOO model (Prepare, Plan, Design, Implement, Operate, and Optimize.) Network engineers at the CCNP level are involved with the implementation planning during the Design phase, and the Implementation itself during the Implement phase.
  • IT Infrastructure Library (ITIL): Emphasizes business requirements and processes as they relate to IT. Implementation and implementation planning are part of its best practices.
  • Fault, Configuration, Accounting, Performance, and Security (FCAPS): Has five network management categories. Implementation and implementation planning are under the Configuration management category.
  • Telecommunications Management Network (TMN): Based on the FCAPS model. Implementation and implementation planning are one of its building blocks.

Each approach includes identifying requirements, creating an implementation plan, implementing the changes, verifying your work, and then documenting it.

Creating an Implementation Plan

To create an implementation plan you need to know what the network looks like now, and what it should look like when you are done. This involves gathering information about the current network parameters such as IP addressing, physical connectivity, routing configuration, and equipment. Compare the current state to what is required. Be sure to include any
site-specific requirements and any dependencies on the existing network.

An implementation plan includes most of the following, some of which might be site-specific:

  • A checklist of tasks to be done
  • Tools and resources needed
  • The schedule of work, coordinated with all needed resources
  • Device configurations
  • Verification processes and tests
Creating Implementation Documentation

Documentation should be kept up-to-date, accurate, and accessible. It includes network information, tools and resources used, implementation tasks, verification methods, device configurations, performance measurements, and possibly screen shots or pictures.

More Resources

About the author


Leave a Comment